Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Spaghetti & Meatballs
20" The Lawn Boy
ROMAN Custom
20" Andolini's Combination
About
Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow
Welcome to Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow, a gem nestled in the heart of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma! Located at 222 S Main St, this pizzeria is redefining the local pizza scene with its mouthwatering offerings and inviting atmosphere. A quick glance at their menu reveals a treasure trove of pizza varieties, calzones, and tempting appetizers that are sure to please any palate. Plus, with their gluten-friendly crust option, everyone can indulge in the pizza experience.
One of the highlights at Andolini's is their signature 20" Demarco of Brooklyn pizza, a true homage to the classic New York style. Topped with DOP San Marzano tomatoes, it delivers bold flavors in every slice. If you’re in the mood for something unique, don’t miss the triple pepperoni with hot honey, an unexpected twist that many patrons rave about. Customers like Jeana Hector have left glowing reviews about their dining experiences, praising both the flavors and the warm service.
Beyond the pizzas, you’ll find delectable appetizers such as Garlic Knots and fried mozzarella, perfect for sharing or savoring solo. And for those with a sweet tooth, the Italian Buttercake awaits—an indulgent fusion of poundcake and cheesecake that visitors like Keli Ireland can’t stop talking about.
But what truly sets Andolini’s apart is the atmosphere. With decor that reflects a friendly, neighborhood vibe, it’s the perfect spot for a casual night out or a family gathering. Customers, like William Burgess, have highlighted the attentiveness of the staff, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.
Andolini's Pizzeria is not just another pizza place. It’s a destination where flavor meets hospitality, making every visit memorable. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make it a point to experience the deliciousness that is Andolini's—you won’t regret it!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ First time eating here. The pizza's are huge, the price is comparable to the size of the pizza's. They offer a gluten friendly crust option for those who need gluten friendly. The waitress was attentive and friendly, even for the place being full. I had a muai muai pizza which was decent and my husband had a Caesar salad. If opportunity arises I will give them another try. ”
“ We came to Andolinis while visiting from out of town. We were very impressed! Everything was good and we had great service. We ordered the triple pepperoni with hot honey pizza which was super good! I also recommend their mac n cheese! It's a cute atmosphere as well and they had the ceiling decorated cute for Christmas time! If we come back to visit again we will be back! ”
“ We love AndoPizza! So many great choices! And if you have an option to sit in Madison’s section do it! She’s the sweetest! ”
“ Great pie! We got the cuped pepperoni and cupped sausage 14". It was enough for four people. Pizza was spicy but not too hot. Fried Mozzarella appetizer was also good. Drinks were great. James T. Pepper PhD is highly recommended. Will definitely return! ”
“ Hands down the best best pizza I have had! The Demarco of Brooklyn is the best. You will have to try it!!! Oh and the whip cream is the after math of the Italian Buttercake. Drink is Bella Dean or something like that is was good ”
“ From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. I tried their classic Pizza Rustica, and it was exceptional — I’ve never had one quite like it here in the States. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, with just the right amount of char from the stone oven. This place is a gem for anyone who loves quality pizza done right. ”
“ Monday night was a perfect crowd and it felt great out on the patio as well. Pizza was fresh and tasty as ever Beer was nice and cold but the homemade Lemon cello was even better! Definitely would be back! Thanks for the great service Brianna! ”
“ We went on a snow day and it was hoppin. We ordered the fried mozzarella and a 20" Demarco. They said the sauce was put on last by mistake (probably wouldn't have noticed, it tasted great) and baked us one made "the right way" to go complimentary. We ordered 4 large gelatos and they were all delicious. Highly recommend. ”